I think
one of the most interesting things about this section is how Sheehy presented
the interviews from the two couples. As I believe her intention was, I thought
that couple A was the older couple while couple B was the younger couple, and I
was shocked when I learned that my belief was mistaken. Though both interviews
said relatively the same thing, there was just something about how each entry
was written to cause me to mistake the identity of each couple. I do wonder
though if this had been altered at all or if the words written were the words
spoken verbatim. Also, how many couples did she ask these questions to? A
sample size of two is far too small to draw any conclusions from.
Another
interesting point that Sheehy brings up is that passages are internally
motivated from people evolving, rather than environmental factors changing
causing people to evolve. I don’t know if I necessarily agree with this. Sheehy
does mention in her outline of the passages that societal pressure does exist,
but I wonder if we lived in a completely different society with different
morals, or perhaps outside of a society altogether, if the passages would
remain the same. I don’t think so, which causes me to believe that the life
passages are externally motivated.
That is what I want the class to discuss: whether or not passages are truly internally motivated.
No comments:
Post a Comment